Keeley grew up in Chicago, Illinois. She played lacrosse all four years at St. Ignatius College Prep. She received All-State honors her senior year. During high school she also played with the Lakeshore Lacrosse National Travel program. She then went on to play lacrosse for the Indiana University Women’s Lacrosse Club. While at Indiana, she was the team captain her sophomore through senior years and team president her junior and senior years. She currently coaches the junior varsity team lacrosse at St. Ignatius. She also plays on the Lakeshore Adult team. Keeley is a Special Education Classroom assistant for Chicago Public Schools.